Close

Presentation

Patterns of Variability and Resilient Performance in Provider–Patient–Family Conversations in Neuro-ICUs
DescriptionIntroduction
ICU Provider-Patient Family (PPF) conversations are critical points of information exchange between ICU staff and patient families that determine the patient’s course of treatment and related care outcomes (Calderone et al., 2022; Douglas et al., 2013; Gay et al., 2009). However, variability inherent to patients, their clinical needs and individual journeys through the ICU, and factors such as providers’ availability and their daily workload, contribute to the complexity of the process (Gay et al., 2009; Lu et al., 2025; Reifarth et al., 2025). Ensuring effective PPF conversations, therefore, calls for adaptive coordination among staff and with patient families.
Several studies have identified factors – clinical and systemic – that influence the effectiveness of ICU-PPF conversations (Gay et al., 2009; Loghmani et al., 2013; Seaman et al., 2017). However, those studies do not consider the variable coordination demand associated with the staff’s planning, preparing, conducting and following up on these conversations, and strategies to manage the emergent trade-offs between countervailing pressures.

This study aims to identify key constituents of adaptive capacity surrounding ICU-PPF conversations. To this end, the study maps major patterns of variability in workflows related to coordinating PPF conversations in a neurological ICU. The mapping identifies the important pressures and trade-offs that staff have to contend with, adaptive strategies, and coordination mechanisms that support adaptive capacity.

Methodology
The primary method of data collection was semi-structured interviews with providers. Interview questions were designed based on the Systems Engineering Initiative for Patient Safety (SEIPS) 2.0 framework, which considers five components: People, Organization, Tools and Technology, Built Environment, and Tasks. Questions were adapted from an existing protocol developed by the Center for Quality and Productivity Improvement at the University of Wisconsin–Madison (Holden et al., 2013).

Participants included nurses, intensivists, advanced practice providers (APPs), and palliative care physicians, recruited through snowball sampling. A total of 26 participants were interviewed. All interviews were audio recorded and subsequently transcribed for analysis.

Qualitative data analysis was conducted in two phases. The first involved a deductive-inductive approach. The data were classified deductively according to main categories—pressures and priorities, adaptive performance, coordination, and decision-making—based on resilience engineering concepts (Hollnagel et al., 2013). Thematic codes within each category were then identified inductively. Two coders separately coded the initial two interviews, then reconciled each other’s codes to form a codebook with definitions. One primary coder then identified themes for the remaining interviews, while updating the codebook, as necessary.

In the second phase, frequently observed “resilience patterns” were identified. A resilience pattern illustrates the relationship across adaptive strategies, pressures and the underlying coordination mechanisms in the context of specific workflow scenarios. Reported trade-offs between conflicting pressures were also documented. Additionally, the analysis captured nominal workflows as well as adaptive workflow patterns based on varying pressures. This phased of the analysis was conducted by the primary coder in intermittent consultation with the senior author regarding alignment of patterns with resilience engineering concepts.

Findings:
Based on the frequency of the codes the major themes identified in each category in the first phase were:
Pressures, Priorities and Challenges:
(i) Patient condition uncertainty – can vary greatly based on the type of condition, acuity, history and other factors, which affects the types of decisions to be made about the patient’s treatment, information to be shared, and roles involved.
(ii) Compliance – with rules, regulations and standard protocol requirements. For instance,
(iii) Patient/Family preferences and values – need to be considered in making decisions. Disagreements between family members can impede establishing shared awareness and decision-making.

Adaptive Strategies:
(i) Engagement of additional or alternate roles to support the PPF conversations – roles, such as palliative care physicians, are often called to foster a greater sense of empathy and support, and to help navigate difficult decisions for patient families.
(ii) Resource mobilization: ensuring necessary resources, including equipment, technology and space are available and tailored to the needs of each patient family’s conversation. This may include, for instance, appropriately sized space based on number of family members and staff, technology for virtual attendance, and computer-on-wheels for the clinician to show relevant information (e.g. imaging) to families.

(iii) Communication strategies – to build rapport with family members, alleviate stress, and develop mutual understanding are practiced in order to enable decisions that are in the best interest of the patient.

Coordination:
(i) Establishing shared awareness: Staff communicate with each other at various stages (before, during and after the PPF conversation) to establish common ground, such as on the plan of action.
(ii) Role engagement: Based on the specific patient condition and family members’ needs, appropriate roles, such as palliative care, are notified in advance and engaged in the conversation.

From the second phase of the analysis (ongoing), multiple important resilience patterns have been identified so far. Each pattern represents relationships across thematic categories, i.e. the corresponding pressures, trade-offs, adaptations and coordination mechanisms. One such pattern, is elaborated below:

Navigating Clinical Uncertainty Through Family-Centered Communication: The tension between clinical uncertainty about a patient's condition [uncertainty] and families' care expectations [patient/family preferences and values] creates a critical need for clear communication. To address this, healthcare teams must ensure that family members understand both their patient's current status and how it may evolve. This requires team members to all be on the same page [shared awareness] and have a thorough grasp of the patient's case while also understanding the family’s expectations.
Early conversations play a crucial role in family comprehension by providing more time to process complex information about the patient's status and prognosis. Building rapport with families serves as another vital strategy for understanding their wishes [communication strategies]. The insights families share enable coordination such that providers can align medical updates with family expectations and clarify care goals.
Clinical uncertainty also influences when these conversations begin, which in turn affects how well families understand and process information. This reveals an interconnected relationship between three key variables: uncertainty in the patient's condition, family wishes and expectations, and clinical decision-making about when to initiate discussions.
The above pattern demonstrates how effective communication involves managing trade-offs between medical realities and family needs while navigating the inherent uncertainties of patient care.

Additional patterns are summarized in Table 1 (below).

Pressures or Priorities Adaptations Coordination Mechanisms Trade-Offs Challenges

Pattern: Use of offline methods of communication •
Pressures or Priorities: Need For A formal/follow-up Meeting; Potential logistical issues with in person communication or time constraints •
Adaptations: Flexibility in mode of Attendance or conversation in general •
Coordination Mechanisms: Use of different means of coordination or communication platforms - Phone •
Trade-Offs: Flexibility in mode of attendance versus ease or efficiency of communication • Challenges: Distractions and divided attention in virtual communication channels (as a resultant challenge)

Pattern: Palliative care consultation order •
Pressures or Priorities: Need for coordination and communication: Information requirements in ordering palliative care consultation •
Adaptations: Use of generics/initials/symbols to provide information on the source of the request; Integrated Information Management: Use of EPIC to create and manage the request •
Coordination Mechanisms: Information (that should be delivered to the palliative care physician) is provided when ordering the consultation; Roles (stakeholders) involved in the process; Means of coordination or communication: EPIC •
Challenges: Variability in delivering the notification and information (or lack thereof) (as an existing challenge)

Acknowledgement
The study was funded by Mission Connect, a program of TIRR Foundation.
Event Type
Oral Presentations
TimeTuesday, March 244:10pm - 4:30pm EDT
LocationMurray Hill West
Tracks
Hospital Environments